10 Cozy Cottagecore Sweaters to Treasure This October

There’s something about October that makes sweaters feel like a love letter from the past—soft, warm, and carrying the promise of crisp autumn walks, pumpkin patch afternoons, and candlelit evenings spent curled up with a good book. Every stitch seems to whisper a story, and every cozy layer is a gentle hug against the early chill.

And the best part? You don’t need to buy brand-new to find this magic. Thrifting and secondhand shopping bring all the charm—and the stories—your cottagecore wardrobe could ever dream of. Each piece has character, history, and that delightful feeling that only comes from discovering something rare and meaningful.

This season, I’ve been swooning over sweaters that blend romance, history, and whimsy. From LoveShackFancy’s dreamy knits to Berek’s collectible 80s and 90s sweaters, these are the treasures you’ll want to seek out not just in October, but throughout the fall and into the winter months. Here are 10 cozy cottagecore sweaters that will make you want to grab a warm mug, hunt through racks, and layer in style all season long.

1. LoveShackFancy Knits

Soft pastel cardigans, delicate pointelle patterns, and fluttery ruffled hems—LoveShackFancy sweaters feel like wearing a cloud. They carry that instant French Country charm and romantic nostalgia that makes you want to twirl in the falling leaves. These dreamy pieces often hide in resale shops or on sites like The RealReal—keep your eyes peeled this fall, and don’t hesitate to snag one.

Season to shop: October–December, perfect for layering over dresses or pairing with wool skirts for winter tea parties.

2. Vintage Berek Statement Sweaters

Berek sweaters are stories stitched in yarn—hand-beaded flowers, whimsical appliqués, and unique patterns that almost feel magical. Collectors know these are rare, and when you find one, it’s a little treasure chest of cozy history. Imagine slipping one on for a crisp autumn stroll or a soft winter evening by the fire.

Season to shop: Late October–January, these sweaters are timeless for layering or wearing solo with your favorite boots.

3. Hand-Knit Fisherman Sweaters

Thick, ivory cables in wool or cotton are the epitome of warmth and tradition. Hand-knit fisherman sweaters are staples that feel like a family heirloom, even when newly discovered at a thrift shop. Pair them with a floral skirt for a touch of cottagecore whimsy or with vintage denim for a casual countryside look.

Season to shop: October–March, the coziest layers for autumn walks, hayrides, and winter snow days.

4. Embroidered Cardigans

Picture delicate rosebuds, tiny daisies, or quirky needlework stitched into soft cardigans. Often overlooked on the thrift rack, these little gems are the essence of a cottage garden in sweater form. Wear one to brunch, for a walk in the park, or tucked under a wool coat for a layered, storybook-ready look.

Season to shop: September–December, perfect for autumn afternoons and winter layering.

5. Crocheted Sweaters

Airy, delicate, and often handmade, crocheted sweaters carry a quiet elegance. Soft cotton or wool fibers make them long-lasting, and their vintage charm gives every outfit a handcrafted feel. Layer over a long sleeve dress or under a vest for a textural, autumnal look.

Season to shop: September–November, ideal for crisp days when you want warmth without weight.

6. Ralph Lauren Country Sweaters

Ralph Lauren’s older “Country” line is a goldmine of rustic charm—rich plaids, earthy colors, and structured yet cozy cables. These sweaters are perfect for fall farmers’ markets, hayrides, and layering over skirts or jeans with timeless ease.

Season to shop: October–February, they’ll carry you from crisp autumn mornings to cozy winter nights.

7. Fair Isle Knits

Nothing whispers “autumn and winter” quite like a Fair Isle pattern. Vintage thrifted versions often have more character than new ones, with unique color combinations and the durability of pure wool. Wrap yourself in pattern and warmth—it’s a simple pleasure that instantly feels nostalgic.

Season to shop: October–March, the ultimate winter layering knit.

8. Mohair & Angora Softies

Soft, fuzzy, and almost otherworldly in texture, mohair and angora sweaters feel like a cloud draped around your shoulders. Pastel pinks, soft blues, and creamy whites pair beautifully with skirts, boots, or layered under a thick coat for a day out in the crisp autumn air.

Season to shop: October–December, these delicate layers add romance to your winter wardrobe.

9. Oversized Grandpa Cardigans

Sometimes the best finds are tucked in the men’s section. A slouchy, oversized cardigan with large buttons exudes effortless vintage charm. Belt it over a dress, layer a scarf, or wear it over a long-sleeve tee for an easy, storybook-ready look.

Season to shop: September–February, the ultimate layering piece for every chilly day.

10. Cottagecore “Novelty” Sweaters

Think whimsical motifs: mushrooms, little ducklings, florals, or forest creatures stitched across a cozy knit. Often dismissed as quirky, these sweaters are exactly the kind of whimsical charm that completes a cottagecore wardrobe. Perfect for autumn outings, market trips, or baking days at home.

Season to shop: September–December, ideal for adding playful personality to layered outfits.

Thrifting Tips for October Sweaters

• Check the men’s section. Oversized cardigans and fisherman knits often hide here.

• Feel for natural fibers. Wool, cotton, and mohair last decades longer than synthetics.

• Don’t fear a little wear. Small pilling or minor holes add character—and can often be easily repaired.

• Think beyond the season. Autumn finds can carry you well into winter with the right layering.

Final Thoughts

The perfect cottagecore sweater isn’t about the label—it’s about the feeling. Stumbling across a LoveShackFancy cardigan, a delicate Berek statement piece, or a soft hand-knit fisherman sweater is like discovering a tiny treasure from the past. Each layer tells a story, brings warmth, and adds a touch of magic to your autumn and winter wardrobe.

This October, wrap yourself in comfort, charm, and history. Let your sweaters be more than clothing—let them be cozy heirlooms that carry you through the season, ready for pumpkin patch adventures, candlelit evenings, and snow-dusted mornings.

Brooke

Hello Gorgeous Threads

---

Pin This for Later

Welcome to my cozy corner of the internet! I’m Brooke, and I’m so thrilled you’re here. As a homeschool mom and a lover of all things Cottagecore, I’ve built a life that’s all about creating warmth, charm, and simplicity—and I can’t wait to share it with you!

Cottagecore, for me, is about slowing down and embracing the beauty of intentional living—finding joy in baking fresh bread, tending a garden, or savoring a quiet moment with a cup of tea by a sunny window. It’s about blending the rustic charm of Cottagecore with the refined elegance of French Country style to create a life that feels both beautiful and attainable.

One of my greatest passions is curating unique, timeless treasures that reflect this way of life. Whether it’s a vintage find, a sustainable piece, or a handmade item with a story to tell, I love sharing these special discoveries with you. And now, you can shop these carefully chosen pieces right here! Each item is selected with love, bringing charm, sustainability, and elegance into your home and wardrobe.

This little community of like-minded women makes everything even sweeter. I’m so excited to connect, inspire, and celebrate the magic of Cottagecore together. Thank you for stopping by—it means the world to me. Let’s embrace a simpler, more beautiful life, one lovely find at a time!