Top Thrift Store Brands for Building a Romantic, Vintage-Inspired Closet
In a world that constantly pushes fast fashion and trending logos, it’s easy to miss the quiet beauty of well-made clothing. But here’s the truth—some of the best pieces I’ve ever added to my wardrobe (and my resell shop) weren’t big designer names or viral sensations. They were humble tags I nearly passed over, quietly stitched into garments made from real cotton, silk, and linen—natural fibers that breathe, wear beautifully, and only get better with time.
So today, I want to slow things down with you and share the brands I never skip when I’m thrifting or browsing online. These are the pieces that feel good on the skin, hold up in the wash, and carry a kind of timeless charm that fits perfectly into any Cottagecore or French Country closet.
Joules – English Countryside Charm in Every Thread
Joules is my go-to for that proper British cottage garden look—dainty florals, gingham prints, and thick, high-quality cotton that holds up wash after wash. Their styles feel like something you’d wear picking blackberries or hanging laundry on the line while a kettle whistles nearby. What I love most about Joules is their joyful attention to print—each piece feels thoughtful, a little playful, and very much rooted in simple living. Their dresses and blouses layer well with cardigans and tights in colder weather, and the cotton is some of the best I’ve found in modern brands. You’ll see a Joules dress and feel the difference.
Joie – Quiet Luxury in Silk
Joie is a label you might pass over if you don’t know what to look for. The branding is subtle, and it doesn’t always jump out at first glance—but Joie has produced some of the most exquisite silk tops and dresses I’ve ever found. Their pieces are light and floaty, with gentle draping and understated elegance that makes them perfect for layering with vintage cardigans or pairing with your favorite high-waisted skirt. Their silks are high quality—you can feel the difference right away—and their aesthetic leans romantic, relaxed, and feminine. Perfect for those Cottagecore days when you want to feel like the heroine of your own novel.
Coldwater Creek – A Goldmine of Silks and Naturals
This is one brand I never skip when thrifting. Coldwater Creek may not be a hot fashion name, but it consistently delivers beautiful, well-made clothing in breathable, natural materials. I’ve found stunning silk blouses, cotton knit sweaters, and airy linen blends that wear beautifully and make you feel instantly put together. The prints are often rich—think leafy botanicals, earthy tones, or soft watercolors—and the cuts are feminine, often flattering with just the right amount of ease. Their quality has stood the test of time, and if you’re a reseller, know that these pieces often resell well too. They’re not flashy, but they’re real clothes—made for real women who want beauty and comfort in the same breath.
April Cornell – The Heart of Cottagecore Dressing
If I could sum up Cottagecore romance in one brand, it would be April Cornell. Every time I find one of her dresses or tops, it feels like discovering a page from a storybook. She’s known for delicate florals, cotton lace, pintucks, and vintage-inspired silhouettes that make you want to gather wildflowers or bake a pie from scratch. These pieces are often made from beautiful 100% cotton, and they’re cut in a way that flatters the body without ever sacrificing comfort. They wash well, layer like a dream, and feel authentic. April Cornell pieces are what I reach for when I want to feel both put together and deeply rooted in tradition. If you ever see her label while thrifting, scoop it up and hold onto it. These are heirloom pieces in the making.
Chico’s – Modern Comfort with Timeless Quality
Now, I know what you’re thinking—Chico’s? But hear me out. This brand is one of the most underrated treasures in the thrift store. While it’s not traditionally considered Cottagecore, many of their linen and cotton pieces are absolute gems. Think wide-leg pants with a relaxed structure, flowy tunics, and blouses with embroidered detail or subtle texture. Their Traveler’s Collection often includes beautiful basics in natural fibers, perfect for layering or pairing with a vintage skirt and boots. Chico’s is made for women who value ease, and when styled with intention—maybe belted with a vintage leather wrap or paired with a straw hat—it fits right into a slow-living, nature-loving wardrobe. Don’t dismiss it just because it feels “modern”—Chico’s often surprises me, and I always check the label.
Pendleton – A Legacy of Craftsmanship Beyond Wool
Pendleton is one of those names we associate with wool blankets and heritage plaid, but the brand has so much more to offer—especially if you’re after timeless, durable fashion. Over the years, I’ve found Pendleton pieces made from cotton, silk, and linen that rival designer quality. Their vintage button-downs, summer dresses, and blazers are made with care and built to last. They often have that all-American feel—structured, elegant, and tailored without being fussy. If you see Pendleton in a thrift store, pause. Whether it’s a thick cotton blouse or a linen jacket, you’re likely looking at a piece that was meant to last a lifetime, not just a season.
Vintage Brands That Still Deserve Our Attention
Vintage is where it all began for me—and there’s a reason I keep coming back. Before everything was polyester and fast fashion, clothes were made to last. And while you may have passed over these “grandma brands” before, I’m here to tell you: these are gold for a slow-fashion wardrobe.
Alfred Dunner – Known for soft knits and floral blouses, this brand is full of comfort and sweetness. Their cotton blends are reliable and cozy, perfect for at-home days.
BonWorth – You can always count on BonWorth for ruffles, buttons, gingham, and florals galore. Their older pieces are so well made and practically scream vintage cottagecore.
Leslie Fay – Feminine structure is what Leslie Fay does best. Think sweet collars, nipped-in waists, and silhouettes that make you feel like a vintage film heroine.
Doncaster – Often found in higher-end vintage shops, Doncaster is known for polished separates made from silk and linen. These pieces look like designer but wear like your favorite cozy blouse.
Liz & Co. – A forgotten gem from the Liz Claiborne family, often made with breathable blends and soft tailoring. Great for layering and styling.
Harvé Benard – Understated, elegant, and often overlooked. Their vintage pieces make beautiful wardrobe staples—think blazers, soft trousers, and romantic shells that work with everything.
Let’s Relearn the Joy of Quality
At the end of the day, fashion doesn’t have to be fast to be beautiful. You don’t need the trendiest label to feel special. What you need are pieces that make you feel like you—comfortable, lovely, and rooted in tradition.
These brands? They may not always shout, but they last. They carry stories. And for the Cottagecore soul, they offer exactly what we’re craving: intentional beauty, slow fashion, and timeless quality.
Next time you’re thrifting or shopping secondhand, take an extra moment to flip that tag. Look past the logos. There just might be a hidden treasure waiting for someone who knows how to love it.
With chamomile tea and a heart full of gratitude,
Brooke
Hello Gorgeous Threads
Shop Preloved Cottagecore
Welcome to my cozy corner of the internet! I’m Brooke, and I’m so thrilled you’re here. As a homeschool mom and a lover of all things Cottagecore, I’ve built a life that’s all about creating warmth, charm, and simplicity—and I can’t wait to share it with you!
Cottagecore, for me, is about slowing down and embracing the beauty of intentional living—finding joy in baking fresh bread, tending a garden, or savoring a quiet moment with a cup of tea by a sunny window. It’s about blending the rustic charm of Cottagecore with the refined elegance of French Country style to create a life that feels both beautiful and attainable.
One of my greatest passions is curating unique, timeless treasures that reflect this way of life. Whether it’s a vintage find, a sustainable piece, or a handmade item with a story to tell, I love sharing these special discoveries with you. And now, you can shop these carefully chosen pieces right here! Each item is selected with love, bringing charm, sustainability, and elegance into your home and wardrobe.
This little community of like-minded women makes everything even sweeter. I’m so excited to connect, inspire, and celebrate the magic of Cottagecore together. Thank you for stopping by—it means the world to me. Let’s embrace a simpler, more beautiful life, one lovely find at a time!